Last week I was asked if I could burn a CD with a Moodle course on it, because there was concern that people in Asia-Pacific wouldn’t have reliable internet access.
“Uh, no”, I said.
For a brief time, I was speechless, which is a rare condition for me. There are two huge misconceptions embedded in this question, which I absolutely must write about!
- Anything online can be copied onto a CD or DVD because “electronic is electronic”.
- Internet access is available only in the US and Canada; maybe England.
Electronic media is a broad category, not a single characteristic. The “power of the Internet” requires the Internet.
No, you can not burn a CD of Moodle! The explanation will have to wait for another day. But even if you could, here’s why you would not want to:
- A CD can not be updated, edited, or controlled. Once it is delivered into the hands of the user, it is what it is. If an error is discovered, a change in policy or technology occurs, or any other reason to change the content comes along, the content of that CD can not be changed.
- You can’t track the usage. A CD running on a device isn’t traceable. As the teacher or administrator, you have no idea if the content was viewed, where it was viewed from, or by whom. You have at least some ability to obtain this information within an LMS.
- There is no feedback. Even if you have a fancy CD that is “interactive”, only the program interacts with the user. The teacher (consultant or trainer) does not interact with anyone. There are no chats or forums. Students do not interact, and therefore, don’t learn from each other.
- There is no other advantage that an LMS has to offer. There’s no “My Moodle” or other customization at the user’s end.
In my opinion, a printed book is better than a CD. It’s a little bit larger, but doesn’t require a computer to run, and I can sit under a tree with it.
OK, so those are just a few of the advantages of online learning. Not only is online better, there’s no excuse not to have it. Internet access is ubiquitous. Perhaps we need to revamp Where In the World is Carmen Dandiego to…
…Where in the world is the Internet?
When I was an employee at Time Warner Communications in the mid 1990s, all the buzz was about broadband, a wild, new concept. The vision of our company was to bundle cable TV, phone, and Internet access into one service. There was even talk of a “library of movies that a user could just watch whenever desired”. Revolutionary! Almost as far-fetched as indoor plumbing! Of course, these ideas are very much reality 15 years later.
What was also reality then – and still plagues us today – is the very difficult task of dealing with legacy systems – not just computer programs, but with the infrastructure itself. In parts of the world where reliable phone networks had never been put in place, it was easier to install fiber optics and cell phone towers than it was to replace the old for the new in many parts of the US. Cell towers are often a source of community disdain because they ruin the view. Back then, cellular phones were as common in parts of Africa as in Colorado.
That was a lifetime ago (in technology years), so I did some quick Googling and came up with some interesting statistics on 2010 Internet usage:
- Three-quarters of a billion people use the Internet in Asia, according to Internet World Stats. I don’t know how fast their service is, but it doesn’t take much bandwidth to run Moodle.
- Chinese is the second most spoken language on the internet, according to this Wikipedia article.
- Another Wikipedia article states: Singapore, as a small densely populated island nation and a pioneer, continues to be one of the few countries in the World in which broadband Internet access is readily available to just about any would-be user anywhere in the country, with connectivity of over 99%.
- The Agoda hotel in Thailand has an internet café. I’m willing to bet that there at least as many hotels in Thailand with internet access as in many North American locales.
- With XMGlobal, you can host your own hot spot just about anywhere in the world. So if you’re not lucky enough to be in Singapore, you can still Moodle!
- Registered Moodle sites exist all over the world. Presumably, those places have Internet access reliable enough to use their Moodle sites.
- My favorite myth-dispeller from WebsiteOptimization.com: Japan and Korea are way ahead of the pack in percentage of subscribers who have fiber (faster and more reliable than the wire that hangs in the air along my street). The US is 11th in fiber penetration and 22nd in broadband speed.
In my post about how small businesses (including authors, consultants, trainers, and other entrepreneurs) can expand their client base by using eLearning, it was implicit that this expansion was limited only by the size of your imagination and the value of your services to people worldwide. A lack of access to the Internet should not be a concern!
Last year, I built and hosted a Moodle course for a cruise line. We trained 2000 employees, while they were onboard ships that were sailing in the Gulf of Mexico, the Caribbean, and the open Atlantic. Not one person had an issue with the accessibility of the Moodle site. Not one.
So, if you are being held back by the notion that Moodle won’t work for your business because your clients are “around the world”, let go of that idea. Moodle is available everywhere…